… in effect, already a reality. Even John Fetterman seems to realize it, too.
The Senator from Pennsylvania has tried desperately to pull his fellow Democrats back from their radical abyss for the better part of three years. Fetterman has vocally opposed the party’s anti-Semitic drift, which, with the success of the Democratic Socialists of America in recent weeks, has become more of a sprint. Fetterman has only grown more frustrated and vocal about the direction of the party this year, referring to Graham Platner and other socialists as “the dirtbag caucus,” and now openly accusing Democrat leadership of cowardice when it comes to fighting communism and socialism.
Fetterman has grown so frustrated, in fact, that he gave his first public indication of a possibility of leaving the Democrat Party. He told Sean Hannity last night that his red line will be whether the party adopts an anti-Israel plank. If it does, Fetterman warns, he’s Audi 5000, baby (via Jeff Charles at Townhall):
Sen. John Fetterman explains the one thing the Democratic Party could do to make him leave.
“My real concern is the Democratic Party is going to put it into the platform … as an anti-Israel party” pic.twitter.com/SwaxlFKZaX
— Jeff Charles, Asker of Questions🏴 (@jeffcharlesjr) July 2, 2026
“I don’t know why we have other Democrats, you know, even people that are calling for their jobs in leadership saying ‘you’re next, you’re next,’” he said. “Why can’t you just push back and say these are abhorrent beliefs, you know, communism, socialism.”
The lawmaker continued, saying, “what my real concern is, the Democratic Party is going to become, and put it into the platform, an anti-Israel party, that Israel does not have the right to defend itself and to exist.”
He added, “And the second that becomes a formal part of our platform, that’s the one thing that would push me out of this party because I’m deeply alarmed the way the Democratic Party is going after Israel and allowing rank antisemitism to just flourish, you know, in the left on the campuses as well too.”
The irony of this is, and always has been, that Fetterman won the nomination four years ago as a progressive. He beat Conor Lamb, who at the time ran as a moderate, and won in 2022 despite lingering effects of his serious stroke when progressives rallied around him to keep him in the race. That was no pose, either; Fetterman has a long track record of old-school progressive policy positions.
In four short years, however, Fetterman finds himself without a party simply by sticking to his values and integrity. Unlike the rest of his party, Fetterman never indulged in Trump Derangement Syndrome. Perhaps that is because Fetterman saw how his state aligned to Donald Trump’s style of conservo-populism, or perhaps just because Fetterman managed to keep his perspective amidst the demagoguery and hysteria of almost all of his colleagues. The result has left Fetterman standing firmly on the same ground as he always has rather than look for shortcuts to power to fight Orange Man Bad that would be magnitudes worse than simply riding out the next two years of Trump’s final term in office.
The fact that Fetterman now has begun to speak about an exit from the Democrat Party demonstrates the level of frustration he has now reached. Fetterman has insisted all along that he’s the true Democrat, not the socialist poseurs and especially not the actual Socialists. The rise of the latter threatens the entire identity of the party, though, and its animus toward Israel tips it over into a pro-Islamist party. Fetterman can see it coming, and to a large extent, it’s already here. Democrat leaders such as Kamala Harris and Gavin Newsom are already playing footsie with the DSA and the pro-Islamists, and the lack of any effective pushback from leaders such as Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries makes the writing on the wall impossible to miss.
Unfortunately, that leaves Fetterman politically homeless. Republicans are wooing him now, but if he joined the GOP caucus, he’d be far more to the left than Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski, who routinely raise the ire of Trump populists in the GOP. Fetterman could identify as an independent and then caucus with the GOP for the next two years, but that would leave him without a party in 2028 when he comes up for re-election. Would the Pennsylvania Republican Party endorse him in that situation, or would they try to get their own candidate into that seat? I suspect the GOP would do the latter, especially since Fetterman is unlikely to support most of the GOP agenda.
Maybe Fetterman has had enough of Washington DC and won’t try for a second term – a distinct possibility given his statements over the last few months about the “dirtbag caucus” that’s taking over his party. That would be a shame, as Fetterman appears to be the rare individual in national politics who refuses to sell his soul for the party or for the pocketbook. If he chooses to bow out, we may miss John Fetterman far more than we imagine at the moment.
Editor’s Note: It’s America’s 250th birthday! Help HotAir celebrate the greatest nation in history by honoring its past, defending its present, and preserving its future with reporting you can trust.
Join HotAir VIP and use promo code AMERICA250 to receive 74% off your membership.
