Maybe you’ve seen this story circulating on X. The Daily Mail ran with a borderline fake news headline: “Bullet used to kill Charlie Kirk did NOT match rifle allegedly used by suspect Tyler Robinson, new court filing claims.” The first paragraph of the story dialed that back a bit. [emphasis added]
The bullet that killed conservative commentator Charlie Kirk may not match the rifle used by suspected killer Tyler Robinson, a bombshell new court filing states.
Robinson, 22, is facing capital murder charges and a potential death sentence for Kirk’s murder at Utah Valley University on September 10.
But his defense attorneys now argue that the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives ‘was unable to identify the bullet recovered at autopsy to the rifle allegedly tied to Mr Robinson.’
This news was greeted by some people online as proof that the case against Tyler Robinson is falling apart.
Where are all my neocons who have been “overwhelmed” by the non existent evidence against Tyler Robinson?
You should all be ashamed of yourselves. Hope the money was worth your soul. https://t.co/C88xGoigdR
— Candace Owens (@RealCandaceO) March 31, 2026
Well, Candace, I’m you’re huckleberry. So let’s dive into this. Is the case against Robinson shaky?
In a word: No. What’s actually happening here is the defense is begging the court for another big delay of six months to go through all the evidence. Also, they put together a list of people they intend to call at trial for the defense. And they are suggesting they might call the ATF because it carried out this test on the bullet.
In a Friday court filing, attorneys for Robinson, who is accused of killing Turning Point USA founder Kirk on Sept. 10, revealed that prosecutors intend to call Robinson’s parents and his roommate and romantic partner, Lance Twiggs, to testify at the preliminary hearing.
That hearing is currently scheduled for May 18, although Robinson’s legal team is seeking to delay it by at least six months, citing the scale of evidence they must review…
At the same time, Robinson’s team is attempting to cast doubt on one of the prosecution’s key forensic components: the bullet used in the killing.
According to court filings from the defense, a Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms and Explosives analysis comparing a bullet jacket fragment recovered during Kirk’s autopsy with a rifle obtained by law enforcement was ultimately inconclusive. The fragment was too damaged to definitively match any specific firearm, a limitation that is not uncommon in high-velocity firearm cases.
The defense has suggested that this “inconclusive” result could be “exculpatory.”
The actual statement from the ATF was that the comparison of the bullet “fragment” was inconclusive.
Stop posting that the bullet that killed Charlie Kirk doesn’t match Tyler Robinson’s rifle.
The filing clearly says, “The result of the comparison was inconclusive.” pic.twitter.com/FYjFnqeHuU
— Paul A. Szypula 🇺🇸 (@Bubblebathgirl) March 31, 2026
The defense is claiming this is exculpatory and the press is running with the claim that the bullets don’t match, but again that’s not actually what the ATF said. What probably happened here is that the bullet broke into multiple fragments inside Kirk’s body and, as a result, there were no fragments large enough to conclusively show the marks that would normally be left on an intact bullet by the rifling in the barrel. That does not mean the fragments can’t be matched by other methods. In fact, the FBI is carrying out additional tests.
Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor, says that even if authorities can’t conclusively link the bullet to the rifle, it doesn’t mean Robinson will be acquitted…
An inconclusive report also does not mean the possibility of a match has been ruled out, according to Rahmani.
“It happens all the time,” he says, noting that a piece of evidence can be degraded to a point where it is difficult to conclusively determine if it is linked to something else. “It doesn’t necessarily mean the person is innocent, it doesn’t exclude that firearm.”
In the defense motion, Robinson’s attorneys did note that the FBI was conducting a second bullet analysis and that they have not yet been able to review the ATF’s findings.
I think we all know what will happen if the next FBI test (which I heard will involve a test of the metal used to make the bullet) shows a match. Owens and her fans will pronounce those results are part of a sinister federal cover up and claim the original test was conclusive. But if there’s a cover up, why did the ATF release the inconclusive results in the first place?
Other experts echoed the same assessment of this evidence. This inconclusive finding does not exonerate Tyler Robinson.
“It’s not uncommon for a round that went through a human body, especially if it traveled through tissue, to say conclusively that it’s tied to a specific firearm, because by nature the projectile is supposed to transfer all of its kinetic energy, and it often disintegrates into fragments and whatnot,” said Bernard Zapor, a former ATF special agent in charge and faculty associate at Arizona State University. “The fact that it went through several bone structures, there was going to be very little left.”
As a result, it would be unfair to conclude that the bullet hadn’t been fired out of the rifle police recovered nearby, experts told Fox News Digital.
“Unable to identify is not the same as ruled out,” said retired FBI supervisor agent Jason Pack. “That’s a finding of inconclusiveness, not exoneration.”
Even putting aside the bullet, you still have his parents ID of Robinson in the photos from the scene and his multiple confessions to having committed the crime. One inconclusive test is not going to overcome the other evidence against him.
But there’s literally no way to convince Owens or people like her that they are wrong because they aren’t really interested in evidence. They are interested in clout and clicks from the story they are selling.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy Hot Air’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join Hot Air VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
