It takes a lot of time and training to qualify as a commercial pilot, a health care worker or an educator — which bodes ill for airlines, medical facilities and schools as thousands of baby boomers retire from professions already facing labor shortages.
With the youngest boomers turning 65 by the end of the decade, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce predicts the workforce participation rate will drop from 62.5% to 60.4% over the next six years, saying highly trained veteran employees are hard to replace.
“When you consider the worker shortage we already have, the number of individuals retiring and the declining birth rate, it paints a bleak picture of the number of people we have to fill skilled positions in the future,” Stephanie Ferguson, director of global employment policy and special initiatives at the chamber, told The Washington Times.
Airlines already have cut flights due to a shortage of 10,000 pilots. Nearly 9 in 10 public school districts have struggled to hire teachers. Almost every medical field has reported similar hiring problems.
According to the latest data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, there are about 8.8 million job openings and 6.3 million unemployed people nationwide.
Several analysts interviewed by The Times pointed out there would still be millions of openings if everyone got a job tomorrow, even as nearly 11,000 more boomers retire daily.
“Their exit from the labor market will have the same impacts that we have been experiencing for the last several years since the COVID-19 pandemic,” said Andrew Crapuchettes, CEO of RedBalloon, an Idaho recruitment agency. “Our workforce isn’t getting any younger, and we’re losing the highly skilled workers from the economy. If our demographics continue on this trajectory, innovation and growth will be stunted in the U.S. economy.”
Born amid postwar prosperity between 1946 and 1964, boomers have been retiring for more than 14 years, having amassed unprecedented wealth by securing high-paying jobs, having fewer children and working longer than their parents.
The Census Bureau projects that a record 4.4 million people will reach retirement age this year. By 2030, 20.2% of U.S. residents will be 65 and older.
What’s more, the Pew Research Center has reported that 3.2 million boomers retired between the third quarters of 2019 and 2020, well above the average annual increase of 2 million retirements from 2011 to 2019.
That included K-12 teachers weary of virtual learning, airline pilots who hit the mandatory retirement age of 65 and medical workers exhausted by increased workloads.
Employers have since coaxed some of them into “unretiring.” Nick Bunker, an economist at Indeed, reported in May that Labor Department data showed an estimated 1.5 million retirees had reentered the labor market over the previous year.
Economists say that hasn’t stopped the retirements — or changed the reality that hardly a single boomer will still be working in 2030.
“The pace of retirement of baby boomers has accelerated in the past few years, in particular since 2019,” said Daniel Lacalle, a professor of global economics at IE Business School in Spain. “This is mostly due to a combination of job losses post-COVID and an improvement in savings.”
Retirements have been especially hard on the medical industry, where COVID-19 infection surges overwhelmed providers during pandemic lockdowns.
By 2034, the American Association of Medical Colleges estimates the nation will face a shortage of 37,800 to 124,000 doctors. That includes an expected shortfall of 17,800 to 48,000 primary care physicians, 15,800 to 30,200 surgical specialists and 3,800 to 13,400 medical specialists.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics has identified a need to add more than 275,000 new nurses by 2030.
“The retirement of the baby boomer generation from the health care industry in the U.S. is expected to create significant workforce shortages, potentially leading to increased costs in healthcare services and a strain on the remaining workforce,” said Maddie Wierman, a creative lead at Tebra, a California company that helps medical providers automate their services.
Meanwhile, shortages of K-12 teachers, principals and staff have left public schools scrambling to catch up from pandemic-induced learning losses. Officials have tried everything from loosening teaching certification requirements to reactivating retired teachers as long-term substitutes to cope with a dwindling number of young people entering the profession.
According to the Department of Education’s National Center for Education Statistics, 86% of public schools had trouble hiring teachers entering the 2023-24 academic year, and 83% struggled to hire non-teaching staff.
In an email to The Times, an Education Department spokesperson noted that the Biden administration has made federal funding available to keep older teachers working as long as possible while the talent pipeline catches up.
“The Department has encouraged states and districts to provide flexibility so that retired teachers can come back to work while still receiving pension payments,” the spokesperson said.
Not all professions have the option of hiring back retired workers, however.
In the airline industry, a mandatory retirement age of 65 for pilots has added to worker shortages, which analysts expect to last through 2027. Other labor shortages include airplane mechanics and air traffic controllers, who did not receive training during pandemic travel restrictions.
Last May, the Government Accountability Office reported the number of newly certified pilots and mechanics grew from 2017 to 2022, while the number of people training in pilot schools “has grown in recent years.”
But the agency added that “there may not be enough of them to meet airlines’ needs in the future” as travel demand grows.
The industry has launched recruiting campaigns to meet that demand. Officials at the Pittsburgh Institute of Aeronautics School for Aviation Maintenance in Hagerstown, Maryland, said their enrollment for airline mechanics is up 10% year-over-year and applications are strong.
Hannah Walden, communications manager for the industry group Airlines for America, said major carriers have also adjusted staffing and reduced flights “to reflect current operating realities.” She said the airlines employed 800,000 workers as of October 2023, “the most in more than 20 years.”
“U.S. airlines recognize the importance of securing a pipeline of new employees — pilots, flight attendants, mechanics and others — and have established new pilot training programs, enhanced recruitment efforts and implemented programs to address financial hurdles related to education and training costs,” Ms. Walden said.
But Robert W. Mann, an independent airline analyst and consultant in Port Washington, New York, said limited training resources have slowed the industry from replacing retiring pilots. He noted first officer and captain shortages have hit regional airports the hardest.
“These limitations and similar shortages of … mechanics are likely to continue for several more years, with the timeline governed by rate of air travel demand expansion,” said Mr. Mann, a former American Airlines executive.
For the moment, employers have prioritized hiring older and foreign-born workers. But workforce analysts say the former talent pool is dwindling and the latter cannot provide sufficient numbers due to caps on legal immigration.
HireVue, a Utah-based hiring technology firm, reported last March that 41% of companies had focused on hiring and retaining older employees. Its clients include St. Jude’s Children’s Hospital, Delta Air Lines and the Atlanta Public Schools.
Amanda Hahn, HireVue’s chief marketing officer, said that strategy is a temporary fix.
“We’re at an inflection point where changing demographics are colliding with rapid advancements in technology, and employers need to double down on assessing candidates for their potential rather than just past work experience,” Ms. Hahn told The Times.
“This paradigm shift away from what a person has done in the past to what they can do in the future is one of the ways we’re going to navigate through short-term pain caused by changes such as mass retirement,” she added.